Subscription strategy: Should you organise coffee subscription tiers by flavour?

Jon Dempsey
-
September 2, 2026
Rooftop Coffee Roasters' coffee subscription tiers

Key takeaways

  • Naming coffee subscription tiers after flavour, not brew method, gives customers an instant self-selection cue that needs no specialty knowledge.
  • A flavour-first coffee subscription frees roasters to buy on taste across the harvest calendar rather than sourcing for a fixed extraction style.
  • Storytelling turns a shipment into an experience, and Rooftop’s monthly zine gives subscribers a reason to stay beyond the coffee itself.

For specialty roasters, subscriptions do far more than generate recurring revenue. They strengthen customer relationships and showcase seasonal and limited-edition coffees while locking in predictable business.

Research into subscription retailing points to the same conclusion, with curation and discovery driving much of the appeal. Yet the coffee subscription market has matured, and most roasters now run one, so standing out takes more than fresh roasts each month.

Canadian roaster Rooftop Coffee Roasters rethought a fundamental question: rather than organising subscriptions around brewing recipes, why not organise them around flavour? This may sound obvious, but some roasters miss it.

Taking inspiration from wine club curation, Rooftop’s Coffee Club groups its coffees into two simple flavour categories: The Classic and The Wild. Subscribers pick their poison based on the drinking experience and tasting notes they enjoy.

The result is an approachable coffee subscription for beginners, built around discovery, while keeping experienced drinkers engaged too. We spoke with Keegan Street, co-founder of Rooftop Coffee Roasters in Fernie, British Columbia, about how the company landed on a winning formula. Read on for his insights.

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter

Sign up

Rooftop Coffee Roasters' coffee subscription tiers

Why do the names and framing of coffee subscription tiers matter?

Names matter because they help customers sort. A tier called The Classic or The Wild tells a shopper what the coffee tastes like. A tier called Filter or Espresso only tells them which piece of kit to use.

When Rooftop Coffee Roasters first launched its e-commerce platform, a progressive subscription service wasn’t the top priority. Like many specialty roasters, the company offered coffee subscription tiers based on brew method, but Keegan says the concept never really took off.

“We started offering subscriptions when we launched our website, but we didn’t really have a plan around it,” he explains. “We started with a filter and espresso subscription, and I think we maybe had only two or three subscribers.”

The pandemic prompted the team to revisit the idea. With more people brewing coffee at home, Keegan wanted to create something that felt less like an automated reorder and more like joining a curated club.

“I decided to make it similar to a wine club,” he tells us. “If you’re more into the chocolaty coffees, we have The Classic. If you’re more into the fruity, more adventurous coffees, we have The Wild.”

This simple model uses a logical curation style and accessible language that all coffee enthusiasts understand. Its flavour descriptors serve as instant self-selection cues that require virtually no specialty coffee knowledge, appealing to coffee drinkers across generations and all stripes.

Interestingly, Keegan says customer preferences rarely follow the patterns many roasters expect. “We send wild coffees to the middle of nowhere in Alberta and Saskatchewan, and we sell the classic chocolate coffees into Toronto and Vancouver,” he says. “It’s kind of all over the place.” This shows that cosmopolitan and rural customers cannot be pigeonholed, underscoring the need for variety.

What are the advantages of organising coffee subscription tiers by flavour rather than brew method?

Flavour-first tiers give roasters far more freedom in the green buying calendar. A great coffee earns its place on taste alone, and nobody has to force it into a filter or espresso slot it does not suit.

Rather than sourcing coffees for specific extraction styles, Rooftop curates each month’s coffee subscription around taste. The team selects two 300g single-origin coffees each month to match either The Classic or The Wild flavour profile, whatever method customers use at home.

That approach acknowledges the reality of modern home brewing, especially post-pandemic, when casual sippers are more savvy than ever, having watched countless brewing videos online. Many coffee drinkers now own multiple brewing gadgets, while others frequently experiment with different recipes.

“We tend to leave it open because people brew in all different ways at home,” Keegan explains. Rather than including brew recipes, Rooftop leaves it in customers’ hands. “[Including] a V60 recipe is not necessarily going to be helpful to everybody.”

Behind the scenes, however, the monthly bean curation requires careful planning. Keegan says the team broadly maps coffee subscription lots around harvests, which keeps a reliable pipeline of flavour profiles running through the year.

“If there’s a cool coffee that’s offered to me by a supplier… that could be a good candidate for the subscriptions,” Keegan explains. Long-term subscribers therefore experience both consistency and novelty as the seasons change.

Rooftop Coffee Roasters' coffee subscription tiers

How do curation and storytelling keep coffee subscribers renewing?

Storytelling keeps subscribers renewing because it turns a delivery into an event. Research into curated subscription services finds that the extent to which a brand discloses what it sends shapes how satisfied customers feel.

To stand out and go beyond a coffee info card, Rooftop offers something fun and engaging. Each coffee subscription includes a printed zine that explores the month’s coffees in greater depth, which turns every delivery into a curated experience rather than a simple shipment.

The publication has evolved significantly since its launch. “When we started out, it was kind of like a baseball card-sized info card,” Keegan says. “Now we’re at the point where it’s like a 10- or 12-page zine that goes into the coffees each month and has photos and all that kind of stuff as well.”

The zine delves into farm details, producers, processing methods, and origin stories, helping subscribers build a stronger connection to each cup they make at home. In a market where quality alone no longer sets roasters apart, that context does the real work.

Keegan believes a sense of continual discovery keeps members renewing and engaged. He outlines Rooftop’s coffee subscription benefits as: “The ability to try something new and fresh every month, and having that more direct connection to where the coffee’s coming from.”

For roasters considering launching a coffee subscription, Keegan recommends resisting the temptation to overcomplicate curation too early.

“I would say keep it simple,” he says. “If you lock yourself into an idea that ends up being hard to execute in the long term, it will become a headache.”

That philosophy extends to packaging as well. Rooftop uses the same high-quality bags across its coffee subscription and individual retail ranges, creating visual consistency. Custom labels then differentiate special releases when the team needs them to.

A product matrix with that kind of flexibility – whether for subscription or purely retail – is exactly where packaging partners play an important role. MTPak Coffee gives roasters access to minimum order quantities as low as 200 units, premium print finishes, and sustainable materials, so a distinctive coffee subscription never costs you quality or values.

For help matching your packaging to your subscription model, contact our team.

FAQs

Should you scrap your filter and espresso coffee subscription tiers overnight?
No. Run flavour tiers alongside them first and watch where new sign-ups land. Rooftop’s brew-method subscription drew two or three subscribers, so the switch cost little, but a roaster with an established base should migrate people gradually.

Does a flavour-first coffee subscription make sourcing harder?
It usually makes it easier. Buying on taste rather than extraction style widens the pool of lots you can use. It does require planning around harvest calendars to keep both profiles stocked year-round.

Is a printed zine worth the cost for a small roaster?
Start smaller. Rooftop began with a card the size of a baseball card and grew it over time. The point is context about the coffee, not page count, so a single well-written insert already does the job.

Jon Dempsey
Jon Dempsey

With 14 years of specialty coffee experience, Jon has worked across Canada in a wide range of roles. From managing cafes and organizing national coffee events to competing in SCA and AeroPress championships, his expertise spans green bean sales, barista training, cafe menu and drink recipe development, and equipment sales. Today, Jon combines a background in freelance journalism with deep industry knowledge, channeling this passion into specialized coffee writing.

MTPak Coffee Recommends